Table 1. Risk of bias summary showing judgments about each risk of bias domain in ROBINS-I and overall bias assessment across all domains
Domain 1: Bias owing to confoundingDomain 2: Bias in selection of participants into the studyDomain 3: Bias in classification of interventionsDomain 4 ITT: Bias owing to deviations from intended interventions: effects of assignment to intervention
First author, publication yearLYLJBKBLYLJBKBLYLJBKBLYLJBKB
Margolis 200527 LowLowLowLowLowLowNINI
Margolis 201228 LowLowModerateModerateLowLowNINI
Basak 201329 CriticalCriticalModerateModerateLowLowNINI
Adams 198531 CriticalCriticalNINILowLowNINI
Domain 4: Bias owing to deviations from intended interventions: effect of starting and adhering to intervention Domain 5: Bias owing to missing data Domain 6: Bias in measurement of outcomes Domain 7: Bias in selection of the reported result Overall bias assessment across all domains
LYL JB KB LYL JB KB LYL JB KB LYL JB KB LYL JB KB
NINILowLowLowLowLowLowLowLow
NINIModerateModerateSeriousSeriousLowLowModerateModerate
NINILowLowLowLowSeriousSeriousSeriousSerious
NINININIModerateModerateModerateModerateSeriousSerious
  • Authors: LYL, JB, KB. ITT = intention-to-treat. NI = no information. ROBINS-I = Risk of Bias in Non-randomised Studies - of Interventions.