Table 2 Characteristics of included studies
Study ID ComparisonNumber of participantsPrimary outcomeFollow-up, months
AREA-CHF 200920 Canrenone
Placebo
231
236
Change in LV diastolic volume12
BEST 200321 Bucindolol
Placebo
114
112
Death and heart failure hospitalisation composite19
Borghi 201322 Ramipril
Zofenopril
73
102
Survival73±14
CARNEBI 201323 Carvedilol
Bisoprolol
Nebivolol
61
crossover
NYHA class, biochemistry, and physiological testing6 (2 x 3 crossover)
CELICARD 200024 Celiprolol
Placebo
62
62
Functional score — Goldman score12
CHARM Added 200325 Candesartan
Placebo
1011
1014
Cardiovascular death or unplanned hospital admissions for worsening CHF34
CHARM Alternative 200326 Candesartan
Placebo
1273
1271
Cardiovascular death or unplanned hospital admissions for worsening CHF41
CIBIS 199427 Bisoprolol
Placebo
320
321
All-cause mortality23
CIBIS 199928 Bisoprolol
Placebo
1327
1320
All-cause mortality16
Cicoira 200229 Spironolactone
Placebo
54
52
Physiological or functional improvement12
Cohn 200130 Valsartan
Placebo
2511
2499
All-cause mortality, and combined mortality and morbidity23
Colucci 199631 Carvedilol
Placebo
232
134
Disease progression and death composite12
COMET 200332 Carvedilol
Metoprolol
1511
1518
All-cause mortality58
Dalla-Volta 199933 Delapril
Enalapril
88
91
Physiological or functional improvement12
ELITE II 200034 Losartan
Captopril
1578
1574
All-cause mortality18
Kum 200835 Add on Irbesartan
Placebo
50
50
6MHW, Minnesota (QoL), peak exercise capacity on treadmill12
Liu 201436 Metoprolol
Conventional therapy
77
77
NYHA class, LVESD, LVEDD, LVEF, 6-min walking distance, medication safety6
MAIN CHF II 201437 Bisoprolol
Carvedilol
21
14
Clinical and functional status, mortality rate8
MERIT-HF 199948 Metoprolol CR
Placebo
1990
2001
All-cause mortality12
Munich 199138 Captopril
Placebo
83
87
Cardiovascular-cause mortality33
Pitt 19999 Spironolactone
Placebo
822
841
All-cause mortality24
Riegger 199939 Candesartan 4 mg
Candesartan 8 mg
Candesartan 16 mg
Placebo
211
208
212
213
Increase in exercise tolerance, reduction in NYHA class3
SENIORS 200540 Nevovitol
Placebo
1067
1061
All-cause mortality and time to first CVD admission21
SOLVD 199141 Enalapril
Placebo
1285
1284
Clinical and functional status, mortality rate41.4
SOLVD 199242 Enalapril
Placebo
2111
2117
Clinical and functional status, mortality rate37.4
Sturm 200043 Atenolol
Placebo
51
49
Worsening heart failure or death24
US Carvedilol 200144 Carvedilol

Placebo
Black: 127
Not Black: 569
Black: 90
Not Black: 308
Ethnicity (self-reported), ejection fraction, clinical status, and major clinical events15
Yodfat 199145 Captopril
Placebo
41
43
Functional status3
Zannad 199846 Fosinopril
Placebo
122
132
Cardiovascular mortality and event-free survival12
Zannad 201147 Eplenerone
Placebo
1364
1373
Cardiovascular mortality and event-free survival21
  • 6MHW = 6-minute hall walk. CHF = congestive heart failure. CVD = cardiovascular disease. LV = left ventricular. LVEDD = left ventricular end-diastolic diameter. LVEF = left ventricular ejection fraction. LVESD = left ventricular end-systolic diameter. NYHA = New York Heart Association. QOL = quality of life.